Tuesday, 11 November 2014

EVENT REVIEW: Survival of the Fittest Manchester

Wow. Challenge #20 has now been completed. Who would have thought I’d have got that far. And this week’s challenge turned out to be my 10th OCR – almost exactly a year to the day since I did my first. It is a fantastic hobby and I have failed to meet anyone who has done one and not caught the bug. Go do one people!

So anyway, it is now time for Part 6 of Team MUBU’s "Seriously, How Good Was That?!" Obstacle Course Race Review. The scoring criteria and categories are covered in a previous post which is somewhere on this blog (see bottom left in the Archive).

MEN’S HEALTH SURVIVAL OF THE FITTEST
10km Urban Obstacle/Mud Run
8th November 2014
Manchester

A bunch of us did this in 2013 and decided immediately to sign up for this year at the bargain price of about £25. There have been various ailments and illnesses along the way but we got pretty much everyone to the start line. I ended up running with my sister and a few friends who had a combined 2 obstacle races and 1 marathon (I think) between them. And it was SO much fun – thanks Team “Kinda Competitive”!

General Event Organisation
It is a Rat Race event so you know exactly what you are getting. The online sign up was dead easy, my brother-in-law was able to add everyone’s details in no problem and we had everything we needed sent to us via email the week before. We become so used to how good it is that we forget sometimes that not all races are this well run.
8 – Very Good

Event Facilities
Your typical merchandise stall with the usual T-shirts, hoodies and other assorted branded goodies. There wasn’t quite the big selection of food and drink establishments as I’d like at these events but there was a bar, somewhere to have a wee and get changed. The only concern was the bag drop, which was unmanned and uncovered. You could put your valuables in a valuables tent (which had great security) but I like to have a towel in my bag for after and it would have got soaked if I’d left it there this time.
6 – Above Average

Registration
Quick and easy. Bring your ID, get your race pack and t-shirt and you are good to go. We were early but it looked like they had plenty of people on hand so I don’t think the queues ever got too long or too chaotic. I’d prefer them to open up the Friday evening registration like they did last year but in truth it didn’t really matter too much.
7 – Good

Location
Based at the Etihad Stadium in Manchester (Manchester City FC’s ground for those who don’t know) you would struggle to find an easier location to find. Plenty of parking a short walk from registration and easy to get away from afterwards.
9 – Excellent

On Course Facilities
Only one water station at about 5km. There were plenty of marshals who braved the terrible weather and they were all very friendly and encouraging. Distance markers kept you on track and the route was well marked out.
7 – Good

Warm-Up
Slightly disappointing in all truthfulness. Didn’t last very long and it was a good two or three minutes after we were “warm” before the gun went off. So I was cold again!
6 – Above Average

Variety of obstacles
Easy to get carried away by the 100m or so “river drift” obstacle which was definitely a first for me. The rest of them were pretty standard fare with a reasonable mix of arm/leg/over/under/through.
7 - Good

Obstacle/Run mix
Plenty of running early doors to try and stretch the field out. The first 4km of the race are essentially a road run with the odd obstacle chucked in to break things up. It gets a bit more obstacle heavy in the later stages and once you get off the roads and into the park.
7 – Good 

Terrain
Being an urban race you would expect the terrain to play a key part. It is used pretty well here although sometimes it feels as if a few tricks have been missed. But overall there is enough up and down to keep me happy (though readers of these reviews will know that I’m not a hill man so that means it’s pretty flat).
7 – Good

Post-Race
Rat Race can always be relied upon for a half decent medal and a good quality technical t-shirt in the goodie bag. Black was the colour this year which felt a bit lazy it is all personal preference I guess. The medal is a bottle-opener aswell and the “adult” surprise provided by Durex was a bit unexpected!
7 – Good

Difficulty
Not the toughest course out there, though measurably harder than last year. If you have the will, you will finish this and you will get through most if not all of the obstacles. It is still a challenge though and the typically friendly Manchester weather always adds an extra element that has to be considered
Course: 6 out of 10
Obstacles: 6 out of 10

Overall Thoughts
This was all about the team though. Great banter, some priceless moments and a massive sense of achievement felt by all at the finish line. For me, that is what these events are about. I’m never going to tear the place up, but I’m going to have a lot of fun doing it.

Overall Score
7.0 – A good event, an excellent price (<£30) and a well-run event all adds up to another 7 out of 10 on the Team Mubu scorecard.

The overall scoring has had a slight overhaul though only in the way it has been represented. I think the scores are still the same in most if not all cases. It is still a combination of the 10 criteria scores plus a little bit of “fine-tuning” based on gut feel and general enjoyment.

It is now in increments of 0.5 as below:
10.0 Nothing will ever get 10.0, you should always strive for better
9.5 Sell organs AND children. And everything you own. About as good as it gets
9.0 Sell organs and/or children to do this event every single time
8.5 Highly recommended indeed, this gets booked as soon as it is released
8.0 A very good event, only money or illness would stop this being a yearly thing
7.5 Definitely one to recommend. Not much would keep me away
7.0 On the list for another go, though not necessarily an automatic selection
6.5 Would do this one again if the stars aligned, but wouldn’t break the bank for it
6.0 Was fun but only a very cheap deal and a free weekend would tempt me again
below 6.0 Not found one of these yet. Hope I don’t

EVENT REVIEWS SO FAR
7.5 Reaper Day Race
7.0 Tough Mudder North West
7.0 Survival of the Fittest Manchester
7.0 Spartan Sprint Yorkshire
7.0 Total Warrior Lake District
6.5 Stockton River Rat Race

Next OCR is the Ram Run on 10th January next year. It’s not all sherry and mince pies till then though, there are still a couple of non-OCR challenges on 30th November and 14th December to fit in.

I am however going to do post-race reviews for the other 3 OCRs that I’ve completed prior to introducing this rating system (Pandemonium, Mighty Deerstalker and Yorkshire Warrior). So the next three or four posts will be “mud-heavy” to say the least!!

Till next time,

DT 

No comments: